Skip to main content

Book review: Worry-Free Money by Shannon Lee Simmons, spending without a budget

A review of Shannon Lee Simmons's Worry-Free Money, with a worked example of the capped spending account and a reviewer's three corrections.

By Thomas Tremblay

November 15, 2026

An open notebook with a pen and pencils on a desk.
Photo by Clay Banks on Unsplash
Add Canooq as a preferred source on Google

Nearly everyone feels broke, whatever they earn. That is what Toronto financial planner Shannon Lee Simmons heard from clients for years before writing Worry-Free Money in 2017. She is the founder of the New School of Finance, and her explanation is that life has become more expensive while the pressure to spend, much of it from social media and constant sales, keeps rising. Her fix is not a tighter budget. She argues budgets make people feel broke, which leads to overspending and anxiety.

The book is for anyone who has started a budget, felt guilty by the second week and quit. It is written by a Canadian planner, and RRSPs and mortgages turn up in its examples.

What she suggests instead

Michael James, who writes the Michael James on Money blog, summarized the system in his review. You decide how much has to go to fixed expenses, to meaningful long-term savings and to short-term savings. That money moves automatically into one chequing account the day you're paid. Whatever remains sits in a second chequing account, and that is your spending money, with a hard limit for each pay period. If you run out, you wait for the next pay. The big things are already looked after, so you don't track each coffee.

Simmons says guilt comes from not knowing what you can afford. If you separate the amount you can spend, every purchase is either inside the limit or outside it.

Here is what that looks like with example numbers that are not from the book. Say you take home $4,000 a month. Rent and other fixed bills come to $2,300, you put $500 toward long-term savings and $400 toward short-term goals like holidays and car repairs. That leaves $800 a month to spend however you like, which is about $369 per paycheque if you're paid every two weeks. The monthly budget planner will show you your own version of those four numbers.

Why people give up on budgets

Simmons has two names for the habits that break budgets. "F*ck It Moments" are the times you drop your spending rules altogether, and she says too-strict budgets create a lot of them. The "Inadequacy Influence" is spending to feel good enough, and she suggests a "life checklist" of what really matters to you. Simmons suggests that spending that isn't on the list may be driven by comparison.

She also asks clients to rate their spending from one to five, from unhappy to happy, and cut the spending that doesn't make them happy. A good place to start is recurring charges you've forgotten, and the subscription cost tracker adds them up.

To avoid peer pressure, she recommends talking about money with friends and family, and the book includes five steps on saying no without guilt. Saying plainly that something doesn't fit your spending plan gives you a simple reply.

What it looks like next to a standard rule

If you know the 50/30/20 rule, which splits take-home pay into needs, wants and savings, Simmons' system looks familiar. The difference is the mechanics. Rather than tracking categories, you automate the important parts and cap the rest. James notes that, despite her criticism of budgeting, her approach looks a lot like a budget on the surface. Both are true: it is a budget with the tracking taken out.

Where the savings go is a Canadian question the book can't answer for you. The guide to TFSA vs RRSP vs FHSA sets out which account suits which goal. Melissa Leong's Happy Go Money makes a similar case for a guilt-free spending account.

Three corrections from a careful reviewer

Michael James liked the book and still flagged three problems. When Simmons says spending money fell "10%", she sometimes means 10 percentage points. On $5,000 a month, a drop from 40% to 30% is $500, not the $200 that a 10% drop would be. She also compares the tax on an RRSP withdrawal to the interest rate on a credit card, which, as James puts it, is not a valid comparison, because one is a tax and the other is a borrowing cost. And a couple she calls "debt-free" still had a mortgage, which James points out is still debt.

Worry-Free Money works best for someone with a steady paycheque who needs permission to spend and a simple structure. If you carry high-interest debt, you will want a dedicated payoff plan alongside it.

Cover of Worry-Free Money: The guilt-free approach to managing your money and your life by Shannon Lee Simmons

Worry-Free Money: The guilt-free approach to managing your money and your life

by Shannon Lee Simmons

Collins, 2017.

Check price on Amazon Canada

As an Amazon Associate, Canooq may earn from qualifying purchases.

Share this article

Page details
Written by
Thomas Tremblay
Last updated
November 5, 2026

Sources

Sources

Government pages, book listings and the reviews cited were checked November 5, 2026. Worked examples are Canooq calculations.

  1. Michael James on Money: Worry-Free MoneyotherChecked 2026-11-05
  2. Ratehub.ca: Q&A: Shannon Lee Simmons on Worry-Free MoneyotherChecked 2026-11-05

Cite this page: Canooq.ca, Book review: Worry-Free Money by Shannon Lee Simmons, spending without a budget, https://www.canooq.ca/blog/worry-free-money-shannon-lee-simmons-review

Canooq content is educational and may include affiliate or referral links. It is not financial, tax, legal, immigration, employment, mortgage, real estate, or healthcare advice. Verify official sources and provider terms before acting.